October 24, 2022

What Will Happen if My Personal Injury Claim Goes to Court?

Most lawsuits (about 95%) are settled out of court. This is accomplished by the negotiation of a pre-trial settlement agreement between a plaintiff's lawyer and an insurance company. But what if your case is one of the small percentage in which you, as the plaintiff (the injured party), are denied fair compensation? 



If the insurance company of the person or entity responsible for your injury refuses to agree to a sufficient settlement arrangement, you can file a personal injury case in civil court to seek payment for damages - as long as you are still within the statute of limitations. This designated time limit for filing a civil court case differs in various states, and for various types of cases. In Tennessee, the statute of limitations for filing a personal injury lawsuit is one year following the injury-causing incident. 

However you were injured as a result of the negligence of someone else, whether by:

  • A driver whose vehicle disobeyed a traffic law and impacted you as a pedestrian, or a vehicle in which you were a passenger.
  • A workplace hazard.
  • Another type of negligence by another party. . .

you need to discuss your case with a skilled personal injury attorney. Worried about what will happen if your personal injury case goes to court? There's no need to be nervous.

Let us calm your fears about filing a court case with the following overview of the process. ​


Why Cases Go to Trial

A trial is usually the last resort of a claims process. Insurance companies don't like court cases any more than the individuals filing them. But if they believe the risk of potentially paying more due to a trial verdict is worth the denial to pay the amount you and your lawyer are asking, you'll have no choice but to file a case, to obtain the amount in damages of which you are deserving. 

A skilled and experienced personal injury attorney can fairly assess your case. If the party you believe caused your injury was clearly negligent, an attorney will likely agree to represent you and strive to negotiate a successful settlement. But if the negotiations fail to result in a fair agreement, they will be prepared to take your case to trial - and support and guide you through the entire process.


What is a Personal Injury Trial Like?

It's probably nothing like you may anticipate, if your only courtroom experience is watching crime drama-themed television shows. There are some similarities, but there are definite differences.

A judge will be present to oversee the proceedings, but civil trial verdicts are normally determined by a jury made up of individuals accepted by your lawyer and the attorney representing the insurance company of the negligent party. 

The lawyer representing each side will make an opening statement.

Both sides will submit evidence to support their position, including:

  • Witness statements.
  • Expert testimonies.
  • Accident photos.
  • Surveillance footage.


Both sides will make a closing statement.

The jury will convene privately to make a judgment, following the closing statements.

In a personal injury civil trial, if the jury agrees negligence was a factor in causing your injuries, they must then make two determinations. 

​They must agree on the monetary value of your case. Then they must decide how much negligence can be applied to either side.

  1. Was the defendant completely responsible for your injuries?
  2. Or do your actions show you to be partly responsible - to bear a percentage of the negligence.


If the jury votes that you are less than 100% at fault for your injuries, they will then determine how much compensation you should you receive.

The amount will be reduced by any percentage of negligence they believe you exhibited, which contributed to the injury-causing incident. For example, if you were awarded $100,000 in damages, yet determined to be 30% responsible, you would only receive $70,000. in compensation.   

If you were injured in a vehicle crash or in another manner involving negligence on the part of another, personal injury lawyers like "The Car Wreck Pro Attorneys", at Fox and Farmer, will utilize their extensive skill and experience to present your case. 

A responsible attorney will do so in a manner that minimizes any perceived negligence on your part, to obtain the highest possible damage award. At Fox and Farmer, we'll do the work, and support you in every manner, so you don't have to worry if your claim goes to court.


Will I Have to Make a Statement?

This is the big question. The reason many people accept less than they deserve in a settlement. Some worry they may inadvertently make an inaccurate statement that could hurt their case. But personal injury trials are straightforward and, for the most part, predictable. All you have to do if called as a witness in your own case, is to respond honestly to the questions presented.       

The insurance company's lawyers do have the option of calling you as a witness. But our legal team can anticipate the issues that may be addressed. They will prepare you to respond truthfully, and appropriately, to the probable questions. 

We can then cross-examine you, if needed, to help clarify your statements if we feel the jury may misinterpret the words you chose in your response. So there's no need to fear the potential need to make a statement. 

At Fox and Farmer, we are well-known as skilled Knoxville - Tri-cities - Chattanooga - East Tennessee car, truck, and motorcycle accident attorneys. Our personal injury lawyers also specialize in workplace injury cases. Explore our website to become familiar with all of the services we offer. We are a family law firm and will treat you like family.
Contact us for a free consultation. We're here to help when times are tough. If we believe a personal injury lawsuit is in your best interest, we'll do our best to negotiate a fair settlement, out of court. But even if a fair agreement can't be reached, we're prepared to support you throughout the process if obtaining the amount in damages you deserve requires a court appearance.

Two cars damaged in a collision at an intersection; one teal, one white.
September 8, 2025
Injured in multi-vehicle accidents in Tennessee? Learn how fault is determined and your next legal steps to recover.
September 1, 2025
Here's how to cover the basics of driving in Knoxville with your young driver.
Woman with leg cast reading, seated indoors near a small table with a keyboard.
August 25, 2025
Learn how social media posts can harm your personal injury case and why it’s crucial to consult an attorney as soon as possible
August 12, 2025
Understand how memory after a car accident impacts your claim and how to document details to protect your legal rights.
A legal meeting with hands clasped, a gavel, scales of justice, a laptop, and a person writing.
August 5, 2025
What are interrogatories? Learn how they impact your personal injury case and how a lawyer can guide you through the process.
A man is holding a white board with a question mark in the middle
July 11, 2025
You are fighting a personal injury claim and have been asked to provide a deposition. What does this mean? It's a scary word, but it's not really that hard.
 Two cars collided with a police officer inspecting the accident scene
July 1, 2025
Don't make common mistakes after a car accident! Read our guide to navigate the aftermath, protect your rights, and avoid costly errors.
A man with a broken arm is signing a document while a doctor looks on.
September 6, 2023
What to do after a motorcycle accident? This guide will discuss the benefits of hiring a motorcycle attorney following a motorcycle crash.
A person is holding a bunch of keys in front of a model house.
March 28, 2023
Getting your driver's license is a step towards adulthood and freedom. However, in 2019, there were more than 38 crashes every single day in Tennessee that involved a driver under 18. Young drivers are less experienced and more likely to engage in risky behavior.​So, how can you avoid being part of that statistic? Read More Wear Your SeatbeltYou must wear a seatbelt at all times when driving. You're also responsible for making sure that any passengers you have are belted in. You [...]
A man is inflating a tire on a car in a garage.
March 13, 2023
How safe is your vehicle? You should always ask yourself this question when buying an on-road vehicle. While various factors dictate your safety while on the road, your vehicle is one of the most significant. You might have the best driving experience and follow all the driving laws, but if your car isn't safe, you, your passengers, and other road users aren't safe either. Read More Vehicles come with various safety features depending on the manufacturer and model. So, it's essential t [...]
More Posts